*A-**A+*- 方法 2005-05-31 00:00:00 来源：中国经济学教育科研网论坛 作者：Glaeser 0

确实，古扎拉第的书真的就算了，现在很多本科或研究生教学还用那本书有些说不过去。 wooldridge的现代方法真的是最好的中级计量教科书，论述清晰、实证导向。 有在研究生高级计量经济学课程上取得很好成绩的人，也如此评价————在看了wooldridge的书后才明白怎么做计量。

不太明白为什么GREEN的书在国内被称做圣经，其实就是在AMZON上，这本书得到很多负面评价。

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/customer-reviews/0130661899/ref=cm_cr_dp_2_1/103-2513422-8868607?%5Fencoding=UTF8&customer-reviews.sort%5Fby=-SubmissionDate&n=507846

好的评价，比如

****** Absolute leader among all the Econometrics textbooks , May 3, 2005

Reviewer: Oleg S (Moscow, Russia) - See all my reviews

This book is inspiring!

The coverage is very broad and it can serve as a handbook for graduate students. Even the hardest bits of econometrics are explained in an easy to understand way.

My personal favourites are chapters 16, 17 and 18.

I will definetely buy a hardcover of the next edition of this econometrics masterpiece.

Summing up, it''s one of my favourite books.

差的评价，比如

Trash, March 29, 2004

Reviewer: A reader

The book is comprehensive certainly, but its explanations are so confusing that I just could not understand the differences between GMM, GLS, 2SLS, and IV estimation. Moreover, its index is just about the worst I have ever seen -- it''ll introduce GLS, for example, earlier in the text, but if you look up GLS in the index, it''ll point you to an obscure reference several chapters down! I would recommend getting Hayashi instead for a gorgeous GMM treatment or Davidson & McKinnon for a thorough intuition of linear projections; Greene may be good as a reference but I don''t see it being too helpful. Plus, it''s over-priced.

————————————————————

Fumio Hayashi 的《 Econometrics》则是好评如潮。 很多人纳闷：不知道为什么小日本教科书写的这么好。

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:

A modern and unusal approach, January 27, 2005

Reviewer: Il Vecchio Gufo (USA) - See all my reviews

This is a fine book, but probably not the one you want to buy if you are looking for ONE all-encompassing reference. The approach is interesting, but unusual, with all the pros and cons that come with originality. It is for graduate students, or very advanced undergraduates, as it requires quite a lot of previous knowledge of linear algebra and statistics.

What is unusual about this book is that it covers most topics within a unifying Generalized Method of Moments (GMM) framework. Many many estimators are treated as special cases of GMM. The book is clear, and the notation is mostly OK, even if the chapters on panel data and systems of simultaneous equations are a notational nightmare, partly because of the choice of treating everything in a GMM framework. Another unusual aspect of this book is the emphasis on certain regularity conditions (such as ergodicity) that are usually used in a time-series framework, but are not commonly seen in cross-section analysis. I studied (also) on this book as a graduate student, and overall I liked it. The only real minus are the exercises, which contain so many hints that they become trivial (really, I am not a genius...). Worse, they only require mindless application of linear algebra. One UNimporant cons of this book is the fact that it is... ugly! How could the publisher choose the boring "Times New Roman" font for this book!? But this, of course, does not really matter....

Overall, a useful and good book, but if you are looking for ONE textbook in cross-section econometrics Wooldridge is probably a better choice, and if what you are looking for is ONE book in time series, Hamilton is likely to be what you want on your shelf.

9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:

The Most Readable Econometrics Text There Is. Period, October 18, 2004

Reviewer: econstudent - See all my reviews

I think Hayashi is the best econometrics textbook to come along in a long time. The treatment has that rare quality of being simultaneously sophisticated yet very easy to follow. In that sense, this book is much different than Greene - whereas Greene is (I think) much more of a reference, you can actually sit down and learn a lot of econometrics with this book. Hayashi not only takes the time to explain key concepts in good prose, but in some cases even writes down step-by-step instructions. All this while not compromising the material.

The treatment is also slightly different in that GMM is a central theme instead of something off to the side, which is very nice. There are plenty of empirical examples - these are somewhat helpful, and the exercises are fairly easy but still illustrative.

Two downsides - it would have been nice to see some treatment of Bayesian econometrics, since this appears to be used much more widely (Lancaster is a good supplement). Second, either I got a faulty book, or there are no tables of critical values. This is ultimately a minor gripe since just about every other book has tables (and you really don''t even need them these days with packages and such), but it can be annoying.

Ultimately, the combination of sophistication and readability of this book is what sets it apart from all others. If you''re looking to learn econometrics, buy this book.

（Hayashi的书国图有，武大有影印版。清华上两年上过洪永淼老师高级计量一的同学也有，可以COPY一下。）

Russell Davidson, James G. Mackinnon 的 《Econometric Theory and Methods》也是一本使用比较广泛的教科书。

大牛Takeshi Amemiya （——又是一鬼子）的 《Advanced Econometrics 》出版于1985年，是一本广受赞誉的书。

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:

Excellent reference, but not an easy read!, January 12, 2005

Reviewer: Il Vecchio Gufo (USA) - See all my reviews

This book is justly considered a classic. It has been around for many years, and with some reasons. It provides a very rigorous treatment of many fundamental concepts in cross-section econometrics, such as linear and non-linear models, M-estimation, maximum likelihood, limited dependend variable models. It also has one of the best and more rigorous yet accessible treatments of basic asymptotic theory (the examples and countexamples in this section are uncommonly good). Amemiya is very very rigorous, and this a book where typos and sloppiness do now dwell. Overall, it is not an easy read, though, unless you have a very strong math/stat background, or you are genius. One thing I always liked about this book, indeed, is the very honest title, ADVANCED econometrics, not "Introduction" to econometrics. This book is mostly used as part of the reading list in second-year PhD courses in cross-sectional econometrics. I don''t think it would be a good choice for a first year course. But if econometrics is a serious component of your professional life you will be happy to have Amemiya around, and you will keep reaching for it, once in a while. It is a bit too techinical, difficult, and dry to be my ideal textbook, but it is outstanding nonetheless. I find the chapters on asymptotic theory and limited dependent variables particularly well written. On the minus side, it is now a relatively old book, and you will find here many obsolete technical tools, as well as the absence of many important and modern techniques. In particular, note that you will NOT find anything here about nonparametric and semiparametric techniques, panel data, time series. There are many (very short) empirical applications scattered around the book, but most of them are (necessarily, given the publication year) very very obsolete.

Overall, still a great book highly recommended for people who are into advanced econometrics. But if you want an introduction to cross-section econometrics, you may want to look at other textbooks such as Greene, Ruud, Davidson-McKinnon, Hayashi (more time-series oriented) and especially the "graduate" Wooldridge (Econometric Analysis of Cross-Section and Panel Data), which in my humble opinion is currently the very best option around.

P.S. Harvard University Press also has merit of printing Amemiya on top-quality paper and choosing a very nice format for the book. It''s a pleasure to browse its pages！

12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:

Top choice, January 28, 2000

Reviewer: A reader

Both comprehensive and well-structured this book proves indispensable for anyone delving into the realms of econometrics. Starting from classical least squares the author guides the reader to time series analysis, gls, nonlinear simultaneous equations models up to qr and tobit models. If formulas are a necessary condition for a good study book in econometrics, the clear language of this book fulfills the sufficient condition for any book in this category.

Arthur S. Goldberger 的《A Course in Econometrics》。

Customer Reviews

Average Customer Review:

Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.

0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

Nice starter, October 30, 2004

Reviewer: CCP (New York, New York United States) - See all my reviews

It is a useful book to understand some of the basics in econometrics.

Was this review helpful to you? (Report this)

4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:

Excellent as an introduction and as a reference., September 6, 1999

Reviewer: A reader

This is one of those rare textbooks that manages to be both a good introduction to the subject and a useful reference. Readable on the first try and well organized. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful to you? (Report this)

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:

Terse but very good, May 16, 1999

Reviewer: A reader

This textbook for advanced undergraduates or first-year graduate students leads the reader through the basic concepts and statistical procedures of econometrics. The extensive use of matrix notation allows the reader to easily apply Goldberger''s formulae to actual data (especially with computer packages such as Gauss and Matlab). Although the author gives brief treatments which sometimes require several readings to be fully understood, he is by no means unclear or confusing. Quite the contrary, as the book is very concise. Sections which I found especially useful and interesting were: 22.5 Statistical versus Economic Significance, 23 Multicollinearity (actually humorous!), and 24 Regression Strategies.

Was this review helpful to you? (Report this)

2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

Very readable by your own self., November 2, 1998

Reviewer: A reader

Maybe this is one of the most famous books in classical econometrics now at graduate level. Different from other overwhelming econometrics text books (e.g., Greene), this textbook is very readable and still practical. I liked it.

Goldberger还著有一本初级教科书 《INTRODUCTORY ECONOMETRICS》。

现在中国的学生真的很幸运，因为很多的书在国外出版不久，就被翻译或影印到国内了。

比如 两位时序领域的巨人 James H. Stock, Mark W. Watson 的初中级教科书 Introduction to Econometrics， 我先是看到上海财经大学出了这本 书的影印本，接着又发现东北财经大学出版社 又出版了中文版。

出版周期真的是很快。

有的人除了是好的研究者，还是天生的好的教科书的作者、好的教授。比如已故的G. S. Maddala 教授，他和古扎拉第都是印度人。

他写的初级教科书《 Introduction to Econometrics 》3rd Edition，个人认为要比古扎拉第的好太多了。

参见：http://bbs.efnchina.com/dispbbs.asp?boardID=33751&ID=69716

文章评论

## 中国社会科学院财经战略研究院 2019

根据全国博士后管理委员会和中国社会科学院博士后管理委员会的有关规定，现就中国社会科学院财经战略研...## 南昌师范学院2019年博士人才招聘公告

一、单位简介南昌师范学院前身是成立于1952年的江西省中等师资进修学校，1958年创办江西教育学院，2013...## 北京大学2019年度招聘教学科研人员启事

一、北京大学概况北京大学创办于1898年，是中国第一所国立综合性大学。作为一个集高等教育、学术研究和...

看过本文的人还看过了

Need Help?